You aren’t alone if you believe high-trust leadership walks a fine line between caring for your people and hovering over them. Most supervisors I work with worry about crossing it.

Give too little attention, and you look indifferent; give too much, and you become the micromanager everyone talks about by the coffee machine.

However, I recently found a better model for getting it right, and it came from the bottom of the ocean.

What a dive master teaches us about high-trust leadership

This past week, I interviewed a recreational diver about a guided dive she had just completed. I went in with my workplace questions ready. I’ll confess I asked some of them rather badly, offering her two possible answers before she’d had a chance to give me her own—a habit I would gently correct in any supervisor I was coaching. Thankfully, on this occasion, her answers were far better than my questions.
What struck me was how simple the dive master’s approach was. It was not heroic—just a handful of small, deliberate habits that left a group of experienced divers feeling safe and well looked after.

1. Agree on the signals before anyone gets wet

Before entering the water, the dive master walked the group through the hand signals: I’m okay; I have an ear problem; something is wrong with my regulator.
Underwater, you can’t stop and talk it through. The language for “I’m struggling” had to exist before anyone needed it.
Most workplaces skip this step. We tell people what the job is, yet we rarely tell them how to raise their hand when things start going sideways. Who do they tell? How do they tell them? Will it count against them?
Agree on the signal before the stress arrives.

2. Look back often, and stay within reach

The dive master did not hover. He led from the front, turning around regularly to check on his group, and anyone who needed him could swim over and tap him on the shoulder.
Interestingly, the diver I spoke with didn’t find this attention excessive. She said divers need to know someone is looking out for them.
And that is the real distinction. Micromanagement is attention that serves the supervisor’s anxiety. Good supervision is attention that serves the employee’s confidence.
Check in regularly, make yourself easy to approach, and let people swim their own dive.
Presence is not pressure.

3. Point out the marine life, not just the hazards

This was the habit I liked best. The dive master didn’t only watch for problems. He also pointed out the things worth seeing along the way. His check-ins came wrapped in genuine interest in the experience.
When your only conversations with a team member are about errors and deadlines, every glance over the shoulder feels like an inspection. When you also point out progress, good work, and what’s genuinely interesting about the job, that very same glance feels like support.
You must notice the good, or your attention will only ever feel like surveillance. You have likely felt under surveillance by a manager at some point in your career—and you didn’t like it.
Notice the progress, not just the problems.

4. Add weight quietly when someone can’t get down

To get underwater, divers wear lead weights on a belt to offset their wetsuit’s buoyancy.
When this dive began, everyone else dropped below the surface while my interviewee stayed bobbing on top. Her usual eleven pounds wasn’t enough.
The dive master spotted the issue and quietly added another eight pounds until she could descend with the group. There was no lecture. No fuss. Just the right resource at the right moment.
Sometimes a capable person is stuck at the starting line because the conditions changed, not because they lack the skill. It could be a new system, a heavier caseload, a difficult client. A supervisor’s job is to notice and adjust the support rather than question the person.
Fix the conditions before you question the competence.

5. Build in the pause

On the way up, the dive master signaled the group to wait, holding for three minutes before ascending to the next level. Divers come up in controlled stages for good reason. Rushing to the surface is where the real danger lies.
Workplaces rush to the surface all the time. A project ends, and we sprint straight into the next one. A tough incident wraps up, and nobody stops to debrief. A reorganization lands, and we expect people to perform at full speed the following Monday.
We need to build in a deliberate pause, letting people adjust before the pressure changes again.
A controlled ascent beats a fast one.

6. Make “no” a safe answer

After the first dive, this diver felt no pressure whatsoever to go back in for the second. The dive had been paid for and wouldn’t be refunded, yet sitting it out was clearly a legitimate option. She suspected another diver in the group was weighing that exact decision.
This is where many workplaces get it wrong. An employee who lacks confidence in a task will often press ahead anyway, because saying “I’m not ready” feels riskier than doing it badly. That is how mistakes, injuries, and quiet disengagement happen.
If people can’t say no, their yes means very little.

What signals are you sending?

So, where does that fine line actually sit? It turns out it isn’t about how much attention you give. It’s about what your attention communicates. From start to finish, the dive master sent one consistent message to his group: I can see you; I can help you; the choice is still yours.

Your workplace challenge this month:

  • Does everyone on your team know exactly how to signal that they’re struggling?
  • When you check in, do you point out the good as often as the problems?
  • Could someone tell you “I’m not ready” without paying a price for it?

Answer those honestly, and you’ll know which side of the line you’re standing on.

Lead so that your people feel safe and well looked after, above or below the surface.

Supervise like a dive master.

2026-11-18T09:41:59-07:00

Share This With Your Friends And Coworkers!

About the Author:

Phil Eastwood is a former London Bobby who brings a thirty-five-year career in policing to his role as Senior Partner of Fiore Group Training, a recognized leader in training top North American organizations. Phil is lead author of workplace training courses in respectful workplace training, workplace violence employee training, and leadership training seminars.